Kevlar Strings or Rubber Shock Cords?

 The Thrifty Rocketeer blog continues....

One of the biggest debates among sport rocketeers over recent years has been what glue is best...however, that's not what this entry is about.

Instead, I have heard a lot of guys insist that they hate the rubber shock cords supplied with Estes Rockets kits, and that they ALWAYS replace them with Kevlar string.

This would seem to be problematic unless you plan right from the construction, how to anchor it around either the motor mount or centering ring, or both. (Does this sound familiar?  Haven't we discussed this before?)

I bring this up again because another newby has asked  in another forum, whether he should replace his rubber shock cord, and it sparked a spirited discussion that overwhelmingly leaned toward replacing them, sight unseen, untested, and without recommendation of where to find this.

Some guys are recommending a Kevlar string that is braded, not woven.  Others suggest a shock cord that is at least three times the length of the rocket body.  And only a few have suggested a combination of both rubber shock cord AND Kevlar string, joined together OUTSIDE the body tube.

Now, having experienced more than my share of "Estes Smiles" when the nosecone bounces back and impacts the body tube lip,  I am inclined to try to replace or combine the shock cords in the future.

However, it occurs to me that there is a real benefit to having a rubber shock cord, that is bio degradable.

The major objection to the rubber shock cord these days seems to be that they snap...or that they break...and that produces a problem for the controlled recovery.

However, look at it from the point of view where a rocketeer gets their rocket snagged in a rocket-eating tree, bush, power line, telephone line, etc.  It usually is the shock cord or the parachute that hangs up and dangles the body tube out of reach.  Now, if you can't get the rocket out of the tree, your other option is to keep observing that rocket dangling over time.  Eventually, something gives, and the rocket falls.  It could be a branch. It could be a shroud line.  But more often than not, it's that same rubber shock cord that people have been complaining about snapping.

If it didn't fatigue and snap, your rocket would still be hanging up there.

Frankly, I don't know if this is Estes Rockets' thinking, but I'd like to think they've got a little planned weak link here...just for the benefit of the first-time rocketeers who may loose their rocket to a tree.

What do you think?

Post your comments below please.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

The End of the Line

Image
 The Thrifty Rocketeer blog continues... Well, for years, the state of the model rocket industry relied upon plans and patterns that were photocopied or printed out, and then applied to standard sheets of balsa to be cut out. Eventually, the various parts for various sized rockets were packaged in groups or blister packs, and sold at hobby shops across the nation.  The emphasis was on home brew or building a rocket to specifications and plans. Eventually, entire kits were pre-packaged, with all the parts that one would need.  And then, laser cut shapes, fins or parts were already pre-cut, doing away with the need for most of the patterns and tracing. So what happened to all those bags and bister packs of parts of rockets?  That is, a baggie of various nose cones... or connectors... or transitions or more ?   Many of  those packages remain at your local mom and pop hobby store, just waiting for someone to come in and buy some of their pegboard stock.  And the number and frequency of the
Read more

sleeping with the enemy

Image
 The Thrifty Rocketeer blog continues... First thing I did when they put in a Hobby Lobby in my smaller metropolitan town, 40 miles away, was to grab an application to work there.  Now I know what you're thinking... "How could you?  Who would want to work for that conservative corporation?".. as my daughter would say.  And you'd be partially right. I saved the application and took note of the mailing address. Within the first month or so, most of the initial buying frenzy was over, having sold out of some things, but not everything.   But it seemed nothing new was getting restocked. So, I got on my word processor and wrote a letter to the store management, THANKING them for bringing the store to our isolated metro area. I pointed out that many of the items had sold through completely, and how much we had appreciated their stocking rockets. Then I also encouraged them to restock and consider expanding the display, pointing to the fact that as rocketeers grow older, the
Read more

Death of a Hobby

Image
 The Thrifty Rocketeer blog continues... No, this is not a column about how Model Rocketry is a dying hobby.  It's actually about another sister hobby that sometimes overlaps into Rocketry. I'm talking about Amateur Radio. Just this last weekend, our local Ham Radio club held a "swap meet" which is commonly called a Hamfest.  These gatherings to buy and sell used equipment, parts and visit old friends typically happen just once a year and in the absence of the late Radio Shack, is one of the only places to find parts and electronic elements. There is also testing held to advance to higher licenses. The admission varies depending on the club, their overhead, expense of renting the hall or venue, and the number of tables that they can sell to area vendors who will drive across state with their wares to set up for the half day show. It's not uncommon for amateur radio operators to drive across state to attend, pay admission and get a single entry into the door prize
Read more